[00:00:00] Jason Cottrell: I still see a lot of people, though, coming and saying we’re going to build this big, complicated custom roadmap. That’s actually the one I worry the most about right now because I think those firms are going to be spending a lot of money on something that’s very quickly productized, and they’re just not going to get the return on it.
[00:00:14] Kailin Noivo: Quick one, before we dig in, if you run an online store, we’ve opened up something just for Ecommerce Toolbox listeners. A free trial of Noibu’s AI agents. They find what’s slow, broken, confusing or leaking revenue on your store. They build the change, and nothing ships until you approve it. Grab it at noibu.com/podcast-audit. Okay, back to the episode.
[00:00:34] Kailin Noivo: Welcome to another episode of The Ecommerce toolbox: AI and Retail. Joining us today, we have Jason, who’s a founder and CEO of Orium, but also the president of The MACH Alliance. Welcome, Jason
[00:00:45] Jason Cottrell: Kailin, great to be here.
[00:00:46] Kailin Noivo: Awesome. Jason’s also a fellow Canadian like me, so really excited to have him on the show today. And Jason, we’d love to have you do a brief intro on yourself, how you ended up in your role. Tell us a bit about the business you started and now how you kind of, what MACH is and how now you became the president of MACH as well.
[00:01:02] Jason Cottrell: Yeah, absolutely. So, I am the founder and CEO of Orium, and we’ve been around about 15 years. We’re a systems integrator and consultancy focused kind of on this concept of agentic commerce and what’s the infrastructure that’s going to run autonomous commerce and operations going forward? And by background, you know, we spent kind of over a decade in this concept of composable commerce, composable systems, and I think we’ve built kind of the largest pure-play consultancy in the Americas just doing that. It was interesting. That meant that we’ve been involved for the last few years in an organization called the MACH Alliance. Now the MACH Alliance is an industry association, about 125 members, 250,000 practitioners, 4,000 brands that engage in our programming and events each year. So, really, both a kind of brand and enterprise-side community, as well as a kind of vendor community standards and coordination around customer data commerce and digital experience. So, as we’ve been involved in that, I had the opportunity to take the president kind of mandate for the alliance going forward, help chart what’s the focus of this organization as we skate into this kind of future of agentic, and how’s that going to impact brands? How do we get ready for it? And how can vendors make it easier, cheaper, kind of safer for brands to make that journey and transition?
[00:02:22] Kailin Noivo: Love it. And maybe talk to me a bit about that. You mentioned agentic commerce at the beginning. Does the whole AI era and ecom, does that make composable obsolete? Does it increase the need for it? Like, how do those two kinds of concepts intersect in your opinion?
[00:02:38] Jason Cottrell: So, composable is interesting because I think sometimes there’s this concept of should I go composable or not? And I think the reality is, like, most brands doing over 10 million, but especially those doing over 100 million, it’s not a question of should you go composable - you are - you’re running more than one system to run your customer experience, your commerce, and interact with customer data to run your stores. You’ve got more to run fulfillment, you’ve got more than one system, if you will. So, it’s more a question of how composable should you be and what’s the best way to do it. What’s interesting with the alliance is it spent a lot of time the last few years really trying to have a conversation about, you know, what works, how do you get systems ready for this, how do you get people ready, how do you do composability well? And that included a standard called MACH that the organization published. But we found in our data as we focused more on the agentic future. You know, we study hundreds of brands each year, survey them to pick out, like, where are they in their composable maturity. What are they doing with AI? And the interesting correlation that we found is almost a six-times differential in the success a company will have with AI if they’ve got proper kind of composable foundations, proper MACH foundations in place, than if they don’t, and I think it’s a huge difference, right? When we’re all trying to figure out how do we make sure this works, how do we make sure we’re successful. One of the things that we’re seeing is that the prep for composable foundations helps set that up to run well. It kind of makes sense when you think about it, right? Like, you’ve then upgraded and invested in systems that can be extended, right, that can work well with other systems. You figured out how to onboard new vendors, and many organizations, you know, even have atrophied their ability to bring on new vendors. You’ve built in the ability to bring in new innovative vendors. You’ve often fought for your data; you’ve often, or at least improved, your data foundations. You’ve successfully, you know, started to bring your team on the journey. Often, you work through team and change management from a personnel perspective. All those things kind of make sense when you say those out loud; it sets you up to be more successful in the AI and agentic era. And then the alliance is actually - we’ve coined that kind of MACH foundation. So, a lot of brands engaging in our community are doing it because right now actually they’re just trying to get, say, to Basecamp. Not to Everest, but to Basecamp. How do I get ready for what’s coming?
[00:05:02] Kailin Noivo: Very interesting. And a lot of the people listening to this are on platforms like Shopify, Salesforce, BigCommerce, ones like that. And they’re probably not going to replatform anytime soon. As we know, like, budgets are pretty tight. If they need some sort of composability to build end-to-end agents or to be ready for agent ecommerce, like, how can they realistically do that in a shorter time frame and without having to replatform? Or do they need to consider replatforming to be able to actually do this? Yeah. Curious what your opinion is there.
[00:05:36] Jason Cottrell: I mean, the nice thing is, if we’re talking about commerce vendors, there are a lot of options. You know, one thing I like to say from the start is you probably don’t need to actually really build anything, but you’re gonna have a lot of options on what you can buy and vendors that are spending millions to get it right for you. And I think, you know, most of the modern commerce platforms are investing heavily to bring nice productized capability to their merchants. There are a number of upstart add-on vendors. So, anyone who plays well with plug-ins, other vendors, or kind of add-on capabilities, you know, their ability to work with some of the emerging specialty vendors in this space, right, is going to be to your advantage. So, I think it’s, yeah, you probably don’t need to replatform yet to be ready for what’s coming. Especially this first phase. A lot of it, I think, you can solve, but you’ve got to be asking your commerce partner; you’ve got to be asking and maybe getting, you know, go explore three of the upstarts to help, you know, bridge to how you publish your catalog, how you’ll start to accept orders, find them, speak with them, understand what makes them different, and then you can make a decision on, you know, who in that network will add the capabilities you need. I still see a lot of people, though, coming and saying we’re going to, you know, build this big complicated custom roadmap. That’s actually the one I worry the most about right now because I think those firms are going to be spending a lot of money on something that’s very quickly productized, and they’re just not going to get the return on it.
[00:07:03] Midroll: Quick break from the conversation. Almost every operator we talk to is being asked for the same 3 things: grow revenue, spend less on outside help, and actually get value out of AI, all with the team they already have. That’s why we built Noibu’s AI agents. CRO, A/B testing, performance accessibility, ROAS, and bug resolution. They start by auditing your store and ranking the biggest opportunities. Then they build the change, wait for your approval, ship it and measure what it did. At Totally Bamboo, one person runs all of D2C across more than 600 SKUs. A collection page filter tested off their own shopper data converted 24% better. As a Toolbox listener, you get an exclusive free trial of our AI agents, and it runs until you have at least two changes live and measured. Go to noibu.com/podcast-audit. Now, back to the conversation.
[00:07:53] Kailin Noivo: So, maybe help clarify a few things for the listeners as well. So, you have, like, agentic commerce and then we almost have, like, agentic commerce operations. And what I mean by that is, like, we’re seeing our customers in this space being asked, “Hey, are we ready for agentic commerce? AEO? Search?” How does our product get indexed by ChatGPT or Claude or whatever else? And then on the other side, we’re seeing people being asked to build agents, right, that do more like executional workflow. So, maybe talk to me a bit about on the, on the actual agentic shopping or agentic commerce side, what are you seeing actually in the market be real and tangible in the market today versus just kind of theoretical.
[00:08:39] Jason Cottrell: Yeah. So, I mean, let’s start with what’s real. Right? I mean, the data, I think, is pretty clear. A, not a ton of actual credit card make the payment shopping in Gemini or ChatGPT or Claude or Muse, that’s not happening yet. But product discovery, choosing between product options, is, you know, the majority of Americans are there, right? And that is absolutely a thing. And that’s not going away. Right? The trend towards that is only increasing. And I think the transaction side of it, it’s a matter of when, not if. But today. I think that the most core thing for a brand is getting how your brand, how your products appear in the answer engines, kind of as they’re at training time, but then on demand. And the nice thing is, a lot of these vendors, the upstart vendors I was mentioning, kind of specialized in this, as well as the major platforms, like Shopify or a commerce tool or BigCommerce; they’re forming one-to-one relationships to try to, kind of, basically, get you represented in the search engines; they’re trying to use their scale often, as much as possible, to broker. How do I get your catalog at least, kind of solve that distribution and appearance challenge as best as they can. But there’s a lot more than just, hey, where is this going to happen, kind of in an answer engine, like Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini. I think it’s time for most companies in the next couple of years to think about, yes, how do you start taking payments in those channels? How do you start manifesting your loyalty program in those channels? How do you offer more dynamic experiences in those channels? But I think, and then in parallel, what happens on your own website. Right? So, when the customer comes to one of your owned experiences, how are you thinking about upgrading the experience? Are you going to have agentic capability that helps customers in your own channels and then operations? So, I think, to what you were alluding to behind the scenes: how do you streamline how products come to market, how campaigns are launched, how customers are contacted, how orders are fulfilled, and how order fallout is handled? How do you think about, you know, most of us right now? It’s human-first tasks for that. If you look at the business operations on how a brand’s running, and that’s going to shift in the next few years, and you start to rethink, you know, how do we add maybe accelerants into the process with agentic. But in many cases, the real game comes when you kind of rethink the process end-to-end and then layer a human in just when they’re needed. And that’s coming, I think, very quickly for a lot of brands, and there’s going to be a big kind of cost and competitive advantage to those who get it right sooner rather than later.
[00:11:18] Kailin Noivo: Yeah. So, just to summarize, what you’re saying is, like, the amount of transaction volume going through an LLM is really low right now. But discoverability, especially in certain categories, is climbing in importance, and people are effectively trying to figure it out, including the major ecom platforms, like, how do we enable our customers to be discoverable? Kind of similar to, like, SEO, where it’s like we want to be discoverable on Google searches. Now, people want to be discoverable in these search engines.
[00:11:44] Jason Cottrell: I was going to add, like, the simple question, a simple way of putting it right is if you’re talking to your vendor partners, if you’re talking to upstarts you think might help you solve this problem, hey, you know, what are you doing to help me get listed and be purchasable within answer engines? Where’s your roadmap going? What are you going to be able to do for me? How are you helping me on my owned experiences when someone comes to my website, my app? How are you helping me create new experiences there and improve, like raise the bar for what customers can do? And then three, how do you help me run my business smarter using agentic? How can I rethink using agentic and automation to streamline how I run my business? And you can kind of make sense then of who has strengths and weaknesses in each of those three buckets. But if someone’s in the mix, they should be good at least one of those right now. And then the only other dimension too is when they give you the answer. Is it primarily just for those things within their four walls? Right? Some of these vendors are really good. If it’s one of their agents and their services, and the moment you try to have them work with any third-party system, it all falls apart. Others are getting that down; they’ve got that down pat. They know you’re going to use 6 different products to create and run campaigns. Let’s make sure they can talk together and that their agents can work together. So, figuring out, as well, you know, is it all within their four walls, or is it kind of across systems, and what do you need? And then you can kind of pick up from some of that.
[00:13:04] Kailin Noivo: Very cool. And then to dive a bit deeper on the operation side, I mean, obviously, from the SI side and then from MACH, I’m assuming you’ve been hearing from a lot of different customers, whether it’s on the Orium side or just retailers that are part of MACH, but like what’s actually real in terms of, like, use cases. So, obviously, customer service was well documented pretty early on. But something I keep getting is, like, what jobs to be done are really something that you can reinvent, envision from AI from the ground up?
[00:13:35] Jason Cottrell: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, at a high level, it makes sense, right? Like, we’ve automated a lot, so if it was standard and repeatable, we’ve probably automated a lot of that today. Hopefully, we have. An agentic does well where there’s some repeatability but some variability, and they can handle those use cases very, very well. And so, yes, I think next evolutions in search, right, in product merchandising, product data management, product context, like writing product descriptions, tailoring them for different users, different markets, personalization, they do very well. There’s a bit of structure, but they can do that tailoring and adaptation. These systems do very well for that more agentic means of discovery, right, improving search product discovery, especially for complex catalogs, B2B or kind of being able to be discoverable in the way a customer’s thinking about it. Not keyword search, but being able to, kind of, think about it in long-form questions and answers. How would a product appear? I think that, you know, people have gotten pretty used to hating experiences on websites, but you know, to be able to conversationally answer, kind of, in line with what consumers need to understand about products in a brand, these systems do very well for creating kind of a next tier of customer clienteling and customer service experience. Order, kind of, operations is often very automated, but order fallout, customer communication around order fallout and issues, they can do very, very well with that. So, customer service kind of posts it and, kind of, delivering fulfillment where there’s kind of fallout and issues, which often can be a big part of what consumes teams. I think all of those things are good examples where, and actually, sorry, fraud as well. Fraud. You know, these agentic tools are, I think, creating an interesting dynamic. They’re giving fraudsters a whole new toolbox for fraud and cybersecurity-related threats, and vice versa; in many cases, these are some of the best ways to defend against it, and you know, proving very, very effective to help players like Stripe and Adyen and others, Shopify, upgrade kind of how they can spot fraudulent transactions. So, I think those are some of the ones that come to mind just as we’re kind of exiting 2026, where there’s usually pretty repeatable ROI for investments in each of those spaces. Ideally, as well, it’s how much do you spend, right? Like, as much as possible, those are all pretty productized. There are multiple options through vendors where they just baked it in their platform or add on specialty capabilities that do all the things I just mentioned. And so, it’s kind of, it’s picking the mix, but you don’t have to build it, right? Find a partner, work with them to put it in use, prove the ROI. But you can probably buy the capability and have someone else kind of be the one who evolves and owns it for you.
[00:16:26] Kailin Noivo: Contrary. So, like, flipping the other side, what have you seen that, like repeatedly people are trying to implement, and it just fails?
[00:16:32] Jason Cottrell: I think, I mean, one thing I would say, I think you still want to kind of keep it to where consumers are at in their expectations. So, when I see organizations maybe going too far into creating kind of very complex and very intricate agentic experiences, I think sometimes they execute them very, very well. But consumers aren’t used to using them yet. So, what we’re finding is working better or, you know, I’ve seen brands spending millions or tens of millions creating these kinds of super agents within their own company for their employees to use. And often what’s happening is just they’re too broad. They’re too broad to get it right, to get trained, to specialize, and you have a habit challenge. Consumers only use little parts of the experience. And then when you go back and look at the ROI, you know, it’s been over-invested, or it doesn’t quite act. So, I think one of the lessons for a lot of companies in 2026 that have started down this path is: don’t go overboard, don’t go too broad. Like, you’re better off picking 5 or 10 narrower use cases than having one big blob of capability that you want all of it to work seamlessly. You know, your own little mini ChatGPT. It’s finding the narrow capabilities and putting those in practice for consumers and your staff.
[00:17:49] Kailin Noivo: Very cool. Jason, as we like to wrap up going into next year, what do you think is going to be the biggest kind of thing that takes off that you’re, like, coming into this year, really, AI took off. I don’t know if anyone saw it. It’s always been here kind of in the back of the mind. But the Cowork, kind of, like, Anthropic thing really started to accelerate it. What do you think that kind of equivalent is going to be for commerce next year if you had to place a bet?
[00:18:11] Jason Cottrell: I think in terms of consumer trends, I think that transition towards a more material degree of consumers doing their shopping in line, in an answer engine and wanting to be able to transact in conversation experiences on your own properties, I think you’re going to see a more substantive cohort that is actually doing that in practice. And I think launches of, you know, say Facebook’s Muse, for example, other kinds of personal agent experiences and some of the latest generation experiences coming out from OpenAI and Google, I think all that’s going to accelerate that trend. A lot of the tech to actually make these channels transactable is in place now. The standards are there. So, I think you’re going to see that more. But I think you’ll see consumer trends or consumer preferences match that. I think on the operations side, you mentioned the notion of Cowork, right? And I think a lot of the way we’re using agentic capabilities today, there’s kind of a human in between. We ask the agent to do it; we ask an answer engine to do a thing, then we take that and copy-paste it or do it in a system for the agent. And I think we’re going to see more and more kind of secure, basically, directly connecting the agents with the data, the agents with the systems that can act on this stuff and being able to do so safely. So, I think that idea of that more direct connection and safe direct connection needs to be on people’s minds next year because that’s where you unlock, like, far more substantial gains where you can really start to rethink processes.
[00:19:38] Kailin Noivo: Very cool. Jason, this was a pleasure. I feel like it was overdue and I really, really enjoyed the conversation. Thanks so much for jumping on.
[00:19:45] Jason Cottrell: Absolutely. Thanks so much, Kailin. Thanks, everybody.
[00:19:47] Midroll: Before you go, if today’s conversation has you thinking about what you’d change on your own store, let our agents take the first pass. Until now, a store only got better as fast as the people working on it. That limit’s gone. Our agents find what’s slow, broken, confusing or leaking revenue, build the change, and hand it back for your approval. Toolbox listeners get an exclusive free trial that runs until you have two changes live and measured. Head to noibu.com/podcast-audit. That’s n-o-i-b-u.com/podcast-audit. Thanks for listening. See you next Wednesday.
[00:20:20] Outro: The Ecommerce Toolbox: AI in Retail is brought to you by Noibu. To find out more about Noibu and how we unify error monitoring site performance and experience analytics to uncover growth opportunities and skyrocket your revenue, visit www.noibu.com. That’s n-o-i-b-u.com, and then make sure to search for The Ecommerce Toolbox: AI in Retail on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or anywhere else podcasts are found and click subscribe so you don’t miss out on any future episodes. On behalf of the team here at Noibu, thanks for listening.